What the Jeweller’s Hand Tells the Jeweller’s Brain: Tool Use, Creativity and Embodied Cognition

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Standard

What the Jeweller’s Hand Tells the Jeweller’s Brain : Tool Use, Creativity and Embodied Cognition. / Baber, Chris; Chemero, Tony; Hall, Jamie.

In: Philosophy and Technology, Vol. 32, 15.06.2019, p. 283-302.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Harvard

APA

Vancouver

Author

Bibtex

@article{76150f26059d48f7ae7ab48875d400c8,
title = "What the Jeweller{\textquoteright}s Hand Tells the Jeweller{\textquoteright}s Brain: Tool Use, Creativity and Embodied Cognition",
abstract = "The notion that human activity can be characterised in terms of dynamic systems is a well-established alternative to motor schema approaches. Key to a dynamic systems approach is the idea that a system seeks to achieve stable states in the face of perturbation. While such an approach can apply to physical activity, it can be challenging to accept that dynamic systems also describe cognitive activity. In this paper, we argue that creativity, which could be construed as a {\textquoteleft}cognitive{\textquoteright} activity par excellence, arises from the dynamic systems involved in jewellery making. Knowing whether an action has been completed to a {\textquoteleft}good{\textquoteright} standard is a significant issue in considering acts in creative disciplines. When making a piece of jewellery, there a several criteria which can define {\textquoteleft}good{\textquoteright}. These are not only the aesthetics of the finished piece but also the impact of earlier actions on subsequent ones. This suggests that the manner in which an action is coordinated is influenced by the criteria by which the product is judged. We see these criteria as indicating states for the system, e.g. in terms of a space of {\textquoteleft}good{\textquoteright} outcomes and a complementary space of {\textquoteleft}bad{\textquoteright} outcomes. The skill of the craftworker is to navigate this space of available states in such a way as to minimise risk, effort and other costs and maximise benefit and quality of the outcome. In terms of postphenomonology, this paper explores Ihde{\textquoteright}s human-technology relations and relates these to the concepts developed here.",
keywords = "Creativity, Radical embodied cognitive science, Postphenomonology, Jewellery making, Dynamic systems, Uncontrolled manifold hypothesis",
author = "Chris Baber and Tony Chemero and Jamie Hall",
year = "2019",
month = jun,
day = "15",
doi = "10.1007/s13347-017-0292-0",
language = "English",
volume = "32",
pages = "283--302",
journal = "Philosophy and Technology",
issn = "2210-5433",
publisher = "Springer",

}

RIS

TY - JOUR

T1 - What the Jeweller’s Hand Tells the Jeweller’s Brain

T2 - Tool Use, Creativity and Embodied Cognition

AU - Baber, Chris

AU - Chemero, Tony

AU - Hall, Jamie

PY - 2019/6/15

Y1 - 2019/6/15

N2 - The notion that human activity can be characterised in terms of dynamic systems is a well-established alternative to motor schema approaches. Key to a dynamic systems approach is the idea that a system seeks to achieve stable states in the face of perturbation. While such an approach can apply to physical activity, it can be challenging to accept that dynamic systems also describe cognitive activity. In this paper, we argue that creativity, which could be construed as a ‘cognitive’ activity par excellence, arises from the dynamic systems involved in jewellery making. Knowing whether an action has been completed to a ‘good’ standard is a significant issue in considering acts in creative disciplines. When making a piece of jewellery, there a several criteria which can define ‘good’. These are not only the aesthetics of the finished piece but also the impact of earlier actions on subsequent ones. This suggests that the manner in which an action is coordinated is influenced by the criteria by which the product is judged. We see these criteria as indicating states for the system, e.g. in terms of a space of ‘good’ outcomes and a complementary space of ‘bad’ outcomes. The skill of the craftworker is to navigate this space of available states in such a way as to minimise risk, effort and other costs and maximise benefit and quality of the outcome. In terms of postphenomonology, this paper explores Ihde’s human-technology relations and relates these to the concepts developed here.

AB - The notion that human activity can be characterised in terms of dynamic systems is a well-established alternative to motor schema approaches. Key to a dynamic systems approach is the idea that a system seeks to achieve stable states in the face of perturbation. While such an approach can apply to physical activity, it can be challenging to accept that dynamic systems also describe cognitive activity. In this paper, we argue that creativity, which could be construed as a ‘cognitive’ activity par excellence, arises from the dynamic systems involved in jewellery making. Knowing whether an action has been completed to a ‘good’ standard is a significant issue in considering acts in creative disciplines. When making a piece of jewellery, there a several criteria which can define ‘good’. These are not only the aesthetics of the finished piece but also the impact of earlier actions on subsequent ones. This suggests that the manner in which an action is coordinated is influenced by the criteria by which the product is judged. We see these criteria as indicating states for the system, e.g. in terms of a space of ‘good’ outcomes and a complementary space of ‘bad’ outcomes. The skill of the craftworker is to navigate this space of available states in such a way as to minimise risk, effort and other costs and maximise benefit and quality of the outcome. In terms of postphenomonology, this paper explores Ihde’s human-technology relations and relates these to the concepts developed here.

KW - Creativity

KW - Radical embodied cognitive science

KW - Postphenomonology

KW - Jewellery making

KW - Dynamic systems

KW - Uncontrolled manifold hypothesis

U2 - 10.1007/s13347-017-0292-0

DO - 10.1007/s13347-017-0292-0

M3 - Article

VL - 32

SP - 283

EP - 302

JO - Philosophy and Technology

JF - Philosophy and Technology

SN - 2210-5433

ER -