TY - JOUR
T1 - Providing the results of research to participants: a mixed-method study of the benefits and challenges of a consultative approach
AU - Dixon-Woods, M
AU - Tarrant, C
AU - Jackson, CJ
AU - Jones, DR
AU - Kenyon, Sara
PY - 2011/6/1
Y1 - 2011/6/1
N2 - Background How best to provide the findings of research to study participants remains poorly understood.
Purpose We aimed to develop, deliver, and evaluate a consultative approach to inform provision of feedback about research findings to participants in the Oracle Children Study (OCS). The OCS had identified adverse outcomes for some children whose mothers had been prescribed antibiotics as part of a trial in pregnancy.
Methods An iterative process, including focus groups with OCS participants and consultation with other OCS stakeholders, was used to inform the development of a feedback package, including a results leaflet, for OCS participants. A questionnaire survey of participants' reactions to receiving the results leaflet was conducted. The Kolmogorov-Smirnov two-sample test was used to compare responses between different groups of respondents. Analysis of open-ended comments on the questionnaire was based on the constant comparative method.
Results Three focus groups with study participants provided insight into the potential emotional impact of receiving the results and into how the results might most clearly be explained. Negotiations with other stakeholders identified other priorities, including the need for scientific credibility. These multiple needs had to be balanced. The results leaflet was posted to all 4676 UK OCS participants. Survey responses were received from 1124 (25%) of participants. They indicated that the feedback was mostly well received by participants. Those whose children were affected by conditions associated with increased risk from trial participation were more likely to experience emotional distress on receiving the trial results, but there was also evidence of some other unanticipated impacts.
Limitations This study is limited by the low response rate to the survey.
Conclusions Important lessons can be learned from using a consultative approach to developing feedback about research results for study participants. Especially where the findings are unwelcome, feedback development may involve methodological, ethical, emotional, and practical challenges, be resource-intensive, and need early planning. Clinical Trials 2011; 8: 330-341. http://ctj.sagepub.com
AB - Background How best to provide the findings of research to study participants remains poorly understood.
Purpose We aimed to develop, deliver, and evaluate a consultative approach to inform provision of feedback about research findings to participants in the Oracle Children Study (OCS). The OCS had identified adverse outcomes for some children whose mothers had been prescribed antibiotics as part of a trial in pregnancy.
Methods An iterative process, including focus groups with OCS participants and consultation with other OCS stakeholders, was used to inform the development of a feedback package, including a results leaflet, for OCS participants. A questionnaire survey of participants' reactions to receiving the results leaflet was conducted. The Kolmogorov-Smirnov two-sample test was used to compare responses between different groups of respondents. Analysis of open-ended comments on the questionnaire was based on the constant comparative method.
Results Three focus groups with study participants provided insight into the potential emotional impact of receiving the results and into how the results might most clearly be explained. Negotiations with other stakeholders identified other priorities, including the need for scientific credibility. These multiple needs had to be balanced. The results leaflet was posted to all 4676 UK OCS participants. Survey responses were received from 1124 (25%) of participants. They indicated that the feedback was mostly well received by participants. Those whose children were affected by conditions associated with increased risk from trial participation were more likely to experience emotional distress on receiving the trial results, but there was also evidence of some other unanticipated impacts.
Limitations This study is limited by the low response rate to the survey.
Conclusions Important lessons can be learned from using a consultative approach to developing feedback about research results for study participants. Especially where the findings are unwelcome, feedback development may involve methodological, ethical, emotional, and practical challenges, be resource-intensive, and need early planning. Clinical Trials 2011; 8: 330-341. http://ctj.sagepub.com
U2 - 10.1177/1740774511403514
DO - 10.1177/1740774511403514
M3 - Article
C2 - 21730081
SN - 1740-7753
VL - 8
SP - 330
EP - 341
JO - Clinical Trials
JF - Clinical Trials
IS - 3
ER -