Experiments in farmer collectives in Eastern India and Nepal: processes, benefits and challenges

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Authors

  • Bina Agarwal
  • Stephanie Leder
  • Panchali Saikia
  • Dhananjay Ray
  • Manita Raut
  • Anoj Kumar

Colleges, School and Institutes

External organisations

  • University of Manchester
  • The Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, The Swedish Biodiversity Centre
  • Stockholm International Water Institute
  • Centre for the Development of Human Initiatives
  • International Water Management Institute

Abstract

Do farmers’ collectives which pool land, labour, capital and skills to create medium-sized production units, offer a more viable model of farming for resource constrained smallholders? A participatory action-research project in eastern India and Nepal provides notable answers. Groups of marginal and tenant farmers, catalysed by the project, evolved into four different collective models with varying levels of cooperation, gender composition, and land ownership/tenancy status. Based on three years of action-research, this paper examines how the models evolved and their differential outcomes. All groups have gained from cultivating contiguous plots in their efficiency of labour and machine use for land preparation and irrigation, and from economies in input purchase. Several collectives of tenant farmers have also enhanced their bargaining power vis-a-vis an entrenched landlord class, and thus been able to negotiate lower rents and refuse longstanding feudal obligations. However, the models differ in their extent of economic gain and their ability to handle gender inequalities and conflicts over labour sharing. The paper explores the historical, regional, and cultural factors which could explain such differences across the models. It thus offers unique insights into the processes, benefits and challenges of farmers’ collectives, and provides pointers for replication and further research.

Details

Original languageEnglish
Number of pages32
JournalJournal of Agrarian Change
Early online date21 Jul 2020
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 21 Jul 2020