Abstract
AIM: The optimum surgical approach to splenic flexure cancers (SFCs) remains uncertain. The aim of this survey was to explore the opinions of an international surgical community on the management and outcomes of SFC.
METHOD: A questionnaire was constructed comprising five sections (information about respondents; definition and prognosis of SFC; operative approach; approach in specific scenarios; outcomes) and circulated through an international dissemination committee and social media.
RESULTS: The survey received 576 responses over 4 weeks across 50 countries. There was no consensus regarding the definition of the splenic flexure, whilst the proportion of respondents who did and did not think that patients with SFC had a worse outcome was equal. The overall preferred operative approach was left hemicolectomy [203 (35.2%)], followed by segmental resection [167 (29%)], extended right hemicolectomy [126 (21.9%)] and subtotal colectomy [7 (12%)]. The stated pedicles for ligation varied between resection types and also within the same resection. One hundred and sixty-six (28.8%) respondents thought a segmental resection was associated with the worst survival and 190 (33%) thought it was associated with the best quality of life.
CONCLUSION: This survey confirms a lack of consensus across all aspects SFC treatment. The differing approaches described are likely to represent different beliefs around the variable anatomy of this region and the associated lymphatic drainage. Future studies are required to address such inconsistencies and identify the optimum surgical strategy, whilst also incorporating quality-of-life metrics and patient-reported outcomes. A one-size-fits-all approach is probably not appropriate with SFC, and a more bespoke approach is required.
| Original language | English |
|---|---|
| Pages (from-to) | 660-668 |
| Number of pages | 9 |
| Journal | Colorectal Disease |
| Volume | 26 |
| Issue number | 4 |
| Early online date | 12 Feb 2024 |
| DOIs | |
| Publication status | Published - Apr 2024 |
Bibliographical note
INTERNATIONAL DISSEMINATION COMMITTEEAlgeria: A. Tidjane. Argentina: Argentina Coloproctology Society. Australia and New Zealand: N. Dudi-Venkata, H. Mohan, T. Sammour. Azerbaijan: E. Samadov. Belgium: G. Van Ramshorst. Brazil: G.M. Gomes, G.A. Laporte. Bulgaria: M. Slavchev. China: D. O'Reilly. Egypt: I. Sallam, M. Shalaby. France: E. Duchalais, B. Seeliger. Germany: W. Hohenberger, U. Ronellenfitsch. Ghana: F. Gyamfi. Greece: I. Katsoulis, K. Stamou. India: A. Mehuj, S. Rajan. Ireland: J. Larkin, E. Ryan. Italy: E. Baldini, M. Campanell, G. Canonico, G. Capolupo, M. Caricato, F. Colombo, P. DeNardi, C. Feo, R. Galleano, P. Lapolla, G. Lisi, V. Lizzi, D. Matteo, S. Novello, F. Pata, T. Perra, E. Pinotti, M. Romano, F. Rosa, M. Rottoli, P. Sileri, A. Taddei, L. Tirloni. Japan: H. Ueno. Jordan: F. Fa. Lithuania: A. Dulskas, N. Samalavicius. Morocco: A. Souadka. Mexico: M. Benitez, E. Divan, C. Soule. The Netherlands: H. Kroon. Nigeria: A. Adeyeye, J.G. Makama. Norway: H.L. Thorsen. Romania: F. Grama, I. Negoi. Russia: A. Vardanyan. South Africa: South African Colorectal Society. Spain: J. Escartin, M. Estaire-Gómez, M.H. Garcia, F. Mendoza-Moreno, M. Prats. Sweden: M. Rutegard. Turkey: S. Atici, E. Colak, M. Tanal. USA: D. Keller, S. Wexner.
COLLABORATORS
Algeria: N. Djelali, A. Hebbar, S. Mesli. Australia: Y. Arafat, N. Blefari, T. Chittleborough, Y.H. Lam, S. Stevens. Belgium: E. van Eetvelde. Brazil: A. Awad, M. Coura, C. da Silva Cardial, M. Ebrahim, H. Elfeki, D. Gill, A. Sakr, F.M. Vieira. France: A. Castaldi, J. Loriau, C. Niki, M. Pocard, N. Regent, J.J. Tuech. Ghana: R. Awoonor-Williams. Greece: M. Frountazas, N. Michalopoulos, D. Schizas, T. Sidiropoulos, M. Sotiropoulou, A. Syllaios, P. Vassiliu. Ireland: R. Cahill, M. Flanagan, M. Kelly, N. Lynch, L. O'Connell, J. Ryan. Italy: G. Alemanno, M. Ardu, G. Cerino, G. Gallo, F. Ghignone, I. Iannone, A. Mingoli, I. Montroni, T. Nelli, G. Pellino, M.V. Papa, A. Porcu, D. Sasia, S. Di Saverio, N. Tamini, C. Tanda, P. Ziprin, M. Piccoli. Lithuania: D. Venskutonis. Malaysia: M. Thanapal. Mexico: M. Trego-Avila. Morocco: M. Anass, M. Hamid. New Zealand: A. Lin. Nigeria: A. Adejumo, O. Adewunmi, O. Adeyemi, B. Aminu, I. Chukwu, I. Garzali, S. Irmiya. Pakistan: N.A. Khan. Peru: H.B. Hernandez. Portugal: N. Figueiredo. Romania: E.A. Bonci, O. Gingina, S.T. Makkai-Popa, A.M. Musina. South Africa: D. Lutrin, S. Sifuba. Spain: J.M. Alegre, M. Alvarez-Gallego, P. Baños, V. Carneros, C.J. Gómez-Díaz, S. Jeri-McFarlane, B. Matias, C. Placer-Galán, P. Tejedor, V. Vigorita. Sweden: K. Tsimogiannis. Turkey: C. Akyol, O. Bozbiyik, O. Duzgun, E. Kamer, A. Isik, S. Leventoglu, N. Okkabaz, I. Ozata, V. Ozben, A. Ozcan, O. Ozkan, A. Şanli, E. Sivrikoz, H. Ulgur. Tunisia: P. Okeny. UK: P. Barrow, A. Beggs, A. Bhowmick, S. Chapman, J. Davies, G. Faulkner, N. Heywood, A. Renwick, K. Sahnan, M.H. Siddique, C. Smart, P. Sutton, D. Watt, L.W. Wheldon. USA: M. Whiteford.
Keywords
- Humans
- Colectomy/methods
- Colon, Transverse/surgery
- Surveys and Questionnaires
- Colorectal Neoplasms/surgery
- Male
- Female
- Treatment Outcome
- Middle Aged
- Prognosis
- Aged
